“Passive social media use is more harmful to wellbeing than active use.”
A popular middle position in the social media debate holds that scrolling is the problem, not posting or messaging. If true, it would point to design fixes rather than bans.
The hypothesis was influential after a few early studies, but a systematic review found the evidence mixed and the categories themselves fuzzy. Newer person-specific studies suggest the bigger divide may be between users rather than between types of use.
Consuming content without interacting: scrolling feeds, viewing others' posts and profiles.
Creating content or interacting: posting, commenting, messaging. Some researchers split this into public broadcasting and private messaging, which may have different effects.
When people were assigned to browse Facebook passively, their mood declined over the day compared with those assigned to post and interact, and envy appeared to drive the effect.
Verduyn and colleagues combined a lab experiment with experience sampling: passive Facebook use predicted declines in affective wellbeing over time, while active use did not.
Verduyn et al. (2015). Passive Facebook usage undermines affective well-being. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 144(2), 480–488.
Limitation
Small student samples from an earlier Facebook era; effects on mood over hours are not effects on depression over months.
Social comparison provides a mechanism: passively viewing curated highlights invites upward comparison, while interacting builds social connection, which is protective.
Experiments find that browsing idealised images on Instagram lowers body satisfaction in young women relative to control images.
Fardouly, Diedrichs, Vartanian & Halliwell (2015). Social comparisons on social media. Body Image, 13, 38–45.
Limitation
Active posting also invites comparison, through likes and follower counts. The mechanism doesn't map neatly onto the passive/active split.
A critical review of the literature concluded the passive-harmful, active-beneficial hypothesis is not supported consistently: results vary in direction across studies, and the categories are measured inconsistently.
Valkenburg, van Driel and Beyens reviewed 40 studies and found that many reported no association, or associations opposite to the hypothesis; measures of "passive" use often captured different behaviours.
Valkenburg, van Driel & Beyens (2022). The associations of active and passive social media use with well-being: A critical scoping review. New Media & Society, 24(2), 530–549.
Limitation
A null average across heterogeneous studies does not rule out an effect for specific platforms or users.
Effects differ more between people than between use types. In intensive daily tracking, most adolescents showed no effect of passive use on their wellbeing, a minority felt worse and a minority felt better.
Beyens and colleagues surveyed 63 adolescents six times a day for three weeks: 46% showed no effect of passive Instagram/WhatsApp use on wellbeing, 44% a positive effect and 10% a negative one.
Beyens, Pouwels, van Driel, Keijsers & Valkenburg (2020). The effect of social media on well-being differs from adolescent to adolescent. Scientific Reports, 10, 10763.
Limitation
Small sample; moment-to-moment wellbeing is not depression. But it suggests "which teen" matters at least as much as "which use".
"Passive" and "active" use are measured inconsistently across studies.
Effects of social media use vary considerably between individuals.