How Crux works
Crux is a wiki for disagreements. Instead of articles about topics, every page is a single proposition: one claim that can be true or false. The page maps the dispute around it so a reader can see where the real disagreement lies.
Anatomy of a page
- Meaning & context — what is actually in dispute, and the key terms whose definitions change the answer. Mark a term contested when people disagree on what it means.
- Arguments — the strongest case on each side. Each argument gets its type (empirical, causal, moral, predictive, definitional), its evidence and citation, and its honest limitations.
- Areas of agreement — what both sides accept. Often the most useful part of the page.
- Related propositions — how this claim connects to others: it supports, contradicts or assumes another. Linking to a claim that does not exist yet creates a stub for someone to write.
Guidelines
- Steelman both sides. Write each argument the way its best advocate would. Do not plant weak arguments for the side you disagree with.
- One claim per page. If a claim bundles two things ("X causes Y and should be banned"), split it into two linked propositions.
- Cite. Empirical arguments need sources a reader can check.
- Put limitations on every argument, including the ones you agree with.
- Vote your belief, edit for fairness. The stance bar is where your opinion goes; the page itself should be fair to everyone.
- Disputes about how the page is written belong on its talk page. Every edit is kept in history and can be restored.