P-0029 ● Active

“Hate speech should be legally protected as free speech.”

Community stance
No votes yet
§
Meaning & context

The United States protects hate speech: unless it is a true threat, incitement to imminent lawless action or harassment, the government cannot punish speech for expressing hateful views. Most other democracies, including Germany, France, the UK and Canada, criminalise some forms of it, and the EU's Digital Services Act requires platforms to act against illegal hate speech.

The disagreement turns on two empirical questions and a values question. Does hate speech cause violence and discrimination? Do bans reduce harm or backfire? Can any government be trusted to decide what counts as hateful?

Hate speechContested
▶

Speech attacking or demeaning people on the basis of protected characteristics such as race, religion, ethnicity, sexual orientation or disability. Definitions vary widely across jurisdictions.

Legally protected
▶

The state may not criminally or civilly punish it for its content. Private platforms and employers may still restrict it. Threats, incitement and targeted harassment are separate categories.

Filter by type:
↕
Arguments
6 total
↑ Supporting3
Moral

Governments cannot be trusted to decide which opinions are too hateful to express. Laws aimed at bigots are later used against minorities, dissidents and unpopular causes.

Mchangama documents how hate-speech laws have been used against religious and political minorities, from colonial-era laws in India to prosecutions of activists. The US Supreme Court in Matal v. Tam (2017) unanimously held that the government may not suppress speech because it expresses ideas that offend.

Mchangama (2022). Free Speech: A History from Socrates to Social Media. Basic Books; Matal v. Tam, 582 U.S. 218 (2017).

Limitation

Many democracies with hate-speech laws (e.g. Germany, Canada) remain open societies with robust political debate.

Empirical

There is little evidence that hate-speech laws reduce hatred or violence. Weimar Germany prosecuted Nazi propagandists, and the trials gave them publicity and martyrdom.

Strossen notes that Weimar authorities prosecuted Nazi speakers, including Julius Streicher, multiple times, and argues counter-speech and anti-discrimination law are more effective than censorship.

Strossen (2018). HATE: Why We Should Resist It with Free Speech, Not Censorship. Oxford University Press.

Limitation

Weimar's enforcement was inconsistent and courts were lenient on the right; it is a contested historical example.

Moral

Bad ideas are best defeated by counter-speech, not by driving them underground where they cannot be challenged. Suppression also lets hateful groups claim persecution and signals that their views cannot be answered.

This "marketplace of ideas" rationale runs from Mill's On Liberty to Justice Brandeis's view that the remedy for harmful speech is more speech.

Mill (1859). On Liberty; Whitney v. California, 274 U.S. 357 (1927) (Brandeis, J., concurring); Brandenburg v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 444 (1969).

Limitation

Counter-speech assumes targets of hate speech have an equal voice. Coordinated online harassment can drive them out of public debate.

No arguments of this type on this side.
↓ Opposing3
EmpiricalCausal

Hate speech fuels violence. Anti-refugee posts on social media have been shown to predict attacks on refugees, and propaganda has preceded genocides.

Müller and Schwarz found anti-refugee hate crimes in Germany rose in municipalities with high Facebook use when anti-refugee posts by the AfD peaked, and fell during internet and Facebook outages. The Rwandan radio station RTLM's broadcasts were linked to killings during the 1994 genocide.

Müller & Schwarz (2021). Fanning the Flames of Hate: Social Media and Hate Crime. Journal of the European Economic Association, 19(4), 2131–2167; Yanagizawa-Drott (2014). Propaganda and Conflict: Evidence from the Rwandan Genocide. QJE, 129(4), 1947–1994.

Limitation

Incitement to violence is already unprotected even in the US. These studies show propaganda can lead to violence; they do not show bans on hateful opinions would prevent it.

Moral

Hate speech attacks the dignity and standing of its targets as equal members of society. A well-ordered society should guarantee everyone the assurance that they will be treated as equals in public life.

Waldron argues that group defamation laws protect a public good: the assurance of equal standing for all citizens, which hate speech, especially in visible and lasting forms, undermines.

Waldron (2012). The Harm in Hate Speech. Harvard University Press.

Limitation

This justifies restrictions on visible public defamation of groups; it is harder to apply to private conversations or online speech at scale.

Empirical

Most democracies restrict hate speech without sliding into authoritarianism, and international human rights law requires prohibiting advocacy of hatred that incites discrimination or violence.

Article 20(2) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights requires states to prohibit by law "any advocacy of national, racial or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence"; the US entered a reservation to this article.

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, Art. 20(2); UN Rabat Plan of Action (2012).

Limitation

There have been controversial prosecutions for online posts in some of these countries, illustrating the risk of over-enforcement.

No arguments of this type on this side.
≈
Areas of agreement
3 points
Definitional

True threats and incitement to imminent violence are not protected speech.

Definitional

Private platforms can moderate content more strictly than governments may legally require.

Empirical

Definitions of hate speech vary widely, which makes laws hard to apply consistently.

P-0029 · Last edited Oct 26, 2026 · 1 revision