P-0027 ● Active

“Assisted dying should be available to people who are not terminally ill.”

Community stance
No votes yet
§
Meaning & context

Most assisted-dying laws (Oregon and other US states, Australian states, and the bill rejected by the UK Commons in September 2026) limit eligibility to terminally ill adults with roughly six months to live. A few jurisdictions go further: the Netherlands and Belgium allow euthanasia for unbearable suffering without terminal illness, including psychiatric suffering; Canada has allowed it since 2021 for people whose death is not reasonably foreseeable; Germany's constitutional court recognised a right to assisted suicide regardless of illness.

The question is whether the terminal-illness line is principled. If autonomy and relief of suffering justify assisted dying, it seems arbitrary to exclude people who will suffer for longer. Opponents worry that without the terminal limit, assisted death becomes an answer to disability, poverty, loneliness or inadequate care.

Assisted dying
▶

A doctor prescribing (assisted suicide) or administering (euthanasia) life-ending medication at a competent adult's request, under legal safeguards.

Not terminally illContested
▶

People with serious, incurable conditions causing enduring suffering, whose death is not expected within a set period (often six or twelve months). Mental illness as the sole condition is the most contested subcategory.

Filter by type:
↕
Arguments
6 total
↑ Supporting3
Moral

If the justification for assisted dying is a competent person's right to decide about their own death in the face of unbearable suffering, then life expectancy is irrelevant. Someone facing decades of suffering has, if anything, a stronger claim than someone facing weeks.

Germany's Federal Constitutional Court ruled in 2020 that the right to a self-determined death includes the freedom to take one's life with help from others, and is not limited to serious or incurable illness.

BVerfG, Judgment of 26 Feb 2020, 2 BvR 2347/15.

Limitation

Autonomy may be compromised in exactly the conditions (chronic depression, coercion, dependency) that non-terminal eligibility admits.

Moral

Limiting eligibility to terminal illness discriminates against people with conditions such as advanced multiple sclerosis or severe disability, who may suffer as much but not die soon.

Canadian courts struck down the "reasonably foreseeable death" requirement as unconstitutional in Truchon (2019), leading to Canada's 2021 expansion.

Truchon c. Procureur général du Canada, 2019 QCCS 3792.

Limitation

Disability rights groups argue the opposite: offering death to disabled people but not to others is the real discrimination.

Empirical

Experience in the Netherlands and Belgium shows non-terminal cases remain a small minority, handled with extra safeguards, and people refused often go on to take their lives in worse ways.

In the Netherlands in 2023, of 9,068 euthanasia notifications, 138 involved psychiatric conditions; review committees found almost all cases met legal due-care criteria.

Regionale Toetsingscommissies Euthanasie (2024). Annual Report 2023.

Limitation

Numbers have grown steadily year on year, and review is retrospective, after death.

No arguments of this type on this side.
↓ Opposing3
Empirical

Outside terminal illness, requests are driven more by social circumstances (loneliness, poverty, lack of care) that society could address. Assisted death then becomes a substitute for support.

In Canada's 2024 report, 732 people died under the non-terminal "Track 2". Among them, loss of meaningful activities and independence were the most cited sources of suffering; investigations by Ontario's coroner's MAID review committee have raised concerns about cases involving social vulnerability.

Health Canada (2025). Sixth Annual Report on Medical Assistance in Dying in Canada 2024; Ontario MAID Death Review Committee reports (2024).

Limitation

Similar reasons are cited by terminal patients. Social factors do not make suffering less real.

EmpiricalMoral

For mental illness, it is often impossible to know that a condition is irremediable, and the wish to die can itself be a symptom. Many patients who once requested death later recover.

A review of Dutch psychiatric euthanasia cases (66 cases, 2011–2014) found that over half involved patients who had refused some recommended treatments, and in about a quarter of cases the consulting physicians disagreed about eligibility.

Kim, De Vries & Peteet (2016). Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide of Patients With Psychiatric Disorders in the Netherlands 2011 to 2014. JAMA Psychiatry, 73(4), 362–368.

Limitation

Some patients have had decades of treatment without improvement. A blanket exclusion denies them a choice granted to others.

Causal

Once eligibility moves beyond terminal illness, the boundary has no natural stopping point. Canada expanded eligibility within five years of legalisation, and assisted deaths now account for over 5% of all deaths.

Canada legalised medical assistance in dying for foreseeable deaths in 2016, removed that requirement in 2021, and has scheduled (then repeatedly delayed, now to 2027) eligibility for mental illness alone. MAID accounted for 5.1% of all deaths in Canada in 2024 (16,499 people).

Health Canada (2025). Sixth Annual Report on Medical Assistance in Dying in Canada 2024.

Limitation

Expansion followed court rulings applying constitutional principles, not an uncontrolled slide. Over 95% of MAID deaths are still among people whose death was foreseeable.

No arguments of this type on this side.
≈
Areas of agreement
3 points
Empirical

Some people with non-terminal conditions experience severe, long-lasting suffering that treatment cannot relieve.

Empirical

A request for assisted death can be influenced by depression, social isolation or lack of care.

Moral

Any regime needs safeguards to ensure decisions are voluntary and informed.

P-0027 · Last edited Oct 26, 2026 · 1 revision