P-0020 ● Active

“Immigration lowers wages for low-skilled native workers.”

Community stance
No votes yet
§
Meaning & context

Simple supply and demand suggests that more workers with a given skill should lower that skill's wage. Immigrants also spend, start businesses and complement natives in ways that raise demand for labour, and natives can move into different occupations.

Decades of research have narrowed the debate to a specific question: whether low-skilled natives in particular lose, and by how much. Most studies find small average effects. The best-known dispute, over the 1980 Mariel boatlift into Miami, shows how much depends on which workers you compare and how small the samples are.

Low-skilled native workersContested
▶

Native-born workers without a high-school diploma (or equivalent). Earlier immigrants, often the closest substitutes for new ones, are sometimes considered separately.

Lowers wagesContested
▶

Reduces the wages these workers would otherwise have earned, in the short run (before capital and firms adjust) or the long run.

Filter by type:
↕
Arguments
6 total
↑ Supporting3
Empirical

Re-examining the Mariel boatlift, which suddenly increased Miami's low-skilled workforce by about 8%, the wages of native men without a high-school diploma fell substantially compared with other cities.

Borjas restricted the analysis to non-Hispanic native men aged 25–59 without a high-school diploma and found their wages fell by 10–30% in Miami relative to comparison cities after 1980.

Borjas (2017). The Wage Impact of the Marielitos: A Reappraisal. ILR Review, 70(5), 1077–1110.

Limitation

The subgroup sample is very small (a few dozen per year), and Clemens and Hunt showed a change in the survey's composition in 1980 could account for the measured drop.

Empirical

When Czech commuters were suddenly allowed to work in German border towns, local native employment and wages fell, showing labour markets do not fully absorb inflows in the short run.

Dustmann, Schönberg and Stuhler found the 1991 commuting policy reduced local native employment noticeably, with small negative wage effects, and the losses concentrated among older and lower-skilled workers.

Dustmann, Schönberg & Stuhler (2017). Labor Supply Shocks, Native Wages, and the Adjustment of Local Employment. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 132(1), 435–483.

Limitation

Commuters spent their earnings at home, not locally, so the demand side that normally offsets immigration was weak. Effects were mostly on employment, not wages.

Empirical

The US National Academies' comprehensive review concluded that where negative wage effects exist, they fall on prior immigrants and native workers without a high-school education.

The 2017 report found little long-run effect of immigration on overall native wages and employment, but concluded the most likely negative effects are on earlier immigrants and native high-school dropouts.

National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (2017). The Economic and Fiscal Consequences of Immigration.

Limitation

The same review stresses that estimated effects are generally small and vary considerably across studies.

No arguments of this type on this side.
↓ Opposing3
Empirical

The original Mariel study and later re-analyses find no measurable effect on Miami's low-skilled wages, despite one of the largest sudden labour-supply shocks ever studied.

Card found no effect on wages or unemployment of low-skilled workers in Miami relative to comparison cities. Peri and Yasenov, using a synthetic-control method and broader groups of low-skilled workers, also found no significant effect.

Card (1990). The Impact of the Mariel Boatlift on the Miami Labor Market. ILR Review, 43(2), 245–257; Peri & Yasenov (2019). The Labor Market Effects of a Refugee Wave. Journal of Human Resources, 54(2), 267–309.

Limitation

Miami's economy may have been adjusting through other channels (e.g. reduced migration of natives into Miami), which would hide the effect without eliminating it.

Causal

Immigrants and natives with similar education are imperfect substitutes: natives specialise in tasks requiring language and communication, immigrants in manual tasks. Inflows push natives up into better-paid work.

Foged and Peri found that refugee inflows into Danish municipalities increased low-skilled native workers' wages and occupational mobility over time, as natives moved into less manual, more complex jobs.

Foged & Peri (2016). Immigrants' Effect on Native Workers: New Analysis on Longitudinal Data. AEJ: Applied Economics, 8(2), 1–34; Peri & Sparber (2009). AEJ: Applied Economics, 1(3), 135–169.

Limitation

Occupational upgrading takes time and requires training; older or less mobile natives may not benefit.

Empirical

Immigrants also add to demand by spending, starting businesses and filling complementary roles, so the labour market grows rather than being split among more workers. Meta-analyses find average wage effects close to zero.

Longhi, Nijkamp and Poot's meta-analysis of 348 estimates found the average effect of a 1 percentage point increase in the immigrant share on native wages was about −0.1%, very small.

Longhi, Nijkamp & Poot (2005). A Meta-Analytic Assessment of the Effect of Immigration on Wages. Journal of Economic Surveys, 19(3), 451–477.

Limitation

An average across all natives can mask larger effects on the specific low-skilled group the claim concerns.

No arguments of this type on this side.
≈
Areas of agreement
3 points
Empirical

The average effect of immigration on native wages is small in most studies.

Empirical

Any negative effects are most likely concentrated among workers who are close substitutes for new immigrants, including earlier immigrants.

Causal

Labour markets adjust over time through investment, business formation and occupational change.

P-0020 · Last edited Oct 26, 2026 · 1 revision