“Rent control makes housing less affordable in the long run.”
Economists are unusually united here: surveys of leading economists find almost none who think rent control has improved affordability. Rent control nonetheless remains popular with voters and has expanded in some places (Oregon, California, Berlin, Catalonia).
The disagreement is partly about evidence and partly about values. Rent control clearly benefits sitting tenants by keeping them housed and protecting them from sudden increases. The contested claim is about the market as a whole over time: whether it reduces supply and raises rents for everyone else enough to outweigh those benefits. Modern "second-generation" controls (caps on increases rather than rent freezes) muddy the picture.
Caps on rent levels or on annual increases for existing tenants. "Second-generation" schemes allow inflation-linked increases and reset rents between tenants; "first-generation" freezes are stricter.
Higher average rents across the whole market, including uncontrolled units, and/or reduced supply of rental housing.
When San Francisco extended rent control to small older buildings, landlords converted or redeveloped them to escape it, cutting rental supply and raising rents citywide.
Diamond, McQuade and Qian found landlords of newly controlled buildings reduced rental housing supply by 15%, through condo conversions and redevelopment, likely raising citywide rents by around 5% and offsetting the transfer to protected tenants.
Diamond, McQuade & Qian (2019). The Effects of Rent Control Expansion on Tenants, Landlords, and Inequality. American Economic Review, 109(9), 3365–3394.
Limitation
The same study found rent control substantially reduced displacement of incumbent tenants. Stronger conversion rules could limit the supply response.
Economists across the political spectrum agree that rent control fails as an affordability policy.
In the IGM Forum's 2012 survey of leading US economists, only 2% agreed that rent control had positively affected the amount and quality of affordable housing in cities like New York and San Francisco; 81% disagreed.
IGM Forum (Clark Center), Rent Control survey, 7 Feb 2012.
Limitation
Expert agreement is not evidence in itself. The question asked about older first-generation controls.
Introducing rent control in St. Paul led to a drop in residential construction permits and falling property values, as developers anticipated reduced returns.
After St. Paul, Minnesota passed a strict 3% cap in 2021 that initially applied to new construction too, permits for new residential units fell sharply until the city exempted new buildings; property values fell by about 6–7%.
Ahern & Giacoletti (2022). Robbing Peter to Pay Paul? The Redistribution of Wealth Caused by Rent Control. NBER Working Paper 30060.
Limitation
The permit drop reversed after the exemption, suggesting better-designed schemes avoid the worst supply effects.
Modern rent stabilisation that caps increases (rather than freezing rents) and exempts new construction need not reduce supply, and keeps tenants housed, which has social value not captured in average rents.
Kholodilin's review of over 200 empirical studies found consistent evidence that rent control reduces rents for covered units and tenant mobility, but more mixed evidence on new construction, with effects depending heavily on design.
Kholodilin (2024). Rent control effects through the lens of empirical research: An almost complete review of the literature. Journal of Housing Economics, 63, 101983.
Limitation
The same review found negative effects on quality, maintenance and rental supply in many studies.
The housing affordability crisis is caused by restrictions on building, not by rent control. Rent control protects tenants while supply reforms take years, and the two can be combined.
Studies of high-cost US metros find that land-use regulation explains most of the gap between house prices and construction costs (Glaeser & Gyourko, 2018).
Glaeser & Gyourko (2018). The Economic Implications of Housing Supply. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 32(1), 3–30.
Limitation
This argues supply matters more, not that rent control helps affordability. Rent control may also reduce political pressure to build.
Average rent is the wrong measure. Displacement imposes large costs on tenants (moving, losing schools and social networks, homelessness risk) that a market-wide average ignores.
Diamond and colleagues found that rent-controlled tenants in San Francisco were 10–20% more likely to remain at their address, and much more likely to remain in the city, years later.
Diamond, McQuade & Qian (2019). American Economic Review, 109(9), 3365–3394.
Limitation
Protecting incumbents can come at the expense of newcomers and young people who face higher rents in the uncontrolled sector.
Rent control lowers rents and reduces displacement for tenants in covered units.
Strict rent controls that apply to new construction discourage building.
Increasing housing supply is necessary for long-run affordability in high-demand cities.