“Governments should fund research into solar geoengineering.”
Solar geoengineering, mainly spraying reflective aerosols into the stratosphere, could cool the planet quickly and cheaply, as large volcanic eruptions have done. It would not remove CO2, and it could carry unknown risks, from shifted rainfall to "termination shock" if stopped abruptly.
The claim here is only about research, not deployment. Supporters argue we need to know whether it works and what it would do before a desperate country tries it. Opponents argue research builds momentum toward deployment, weakens the will to cut emissions, and that the technology is ungovernable in principle. The UK has begun funding outdoor experiments; a Harvard field experiment was cancelled after opposition.
Deliberately reflecting sunlight to cool the climate, chiefly stratospheric aerosol injection and marine cloud brightening. Distinct from carbon removal.
Modelling, lab work and small, contained outdoor experiments. Not deployment at climate-altering scale.
Volcanic eruptions show the effect is real: the 1991 eruption of Mount Pinatubo cooled global temperatures by about half a degree Celsius for over a year. Models suggest deliberate aerosol injection could reduce many climate risks, so understanding it is prudent.
Pinatubo injected around 15–20 million tonnes of sulphur dioxide into the stratosphere and cooled global average surface temperature by roughly 0.5°C in 1992.
NASA Earth Observatory, Global Effects of Mount Pinatubo; Soden et al. (2002). Global Cooling After the Eruption of Mount Pinatubo. Science, 296(5568), 727–730.
Limitation
A one-off eruption is not a decades-long programme. Long-term effects on rainfall and ozone are much less certain.
The technology is cheap enough for a single country or even a wealthy individual to attempt. It is better that governments understand it scientifically, and openly, than that the first serious use is by an unilateral actor without research behind it.
The US National Academies recommended a federal research programme of $100–200 million over five years, with governance and transparency built in. In 2025 the UK's ARIA agency launched a £56.8 million programme including small outdoor experiments.
National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (2021). Reflecting Sunlight: Recommendations for Solar Geoengineering Research and Research Governance; ARIA (2025). Exploring Climate Cooling programme.
Limitation
Research by major governments could legitimise deployment by others rather than deter it.
If warming overshoots dangerous thresholds, solar geoengineering may be the only way to reduce temperatures quickly. Refusing to study a possible emergency option is itself a risky choice.
IPCC AR6 assessed that solar radiation modification could limit warming but noted large uncertainties and governance risks, and that knowledge gaps remain significant.
IPCC (2021–2022). AR6 WGI ch. 4 and WGIII ch. 14 on solar radiation modification.
Limitation
Emergency framing can be used to justify premature deployment.
Researching a technological fix creates moral hazard: it signals that emissions cuts can be delayed. Fossil-fuel interests and governments under pressure could use the prospect of geoengineering as an excuse.
More than 500 scientists signed a 2022 call for an International Non-Use Agreement on solar geoengineering, citing moral hazard and the impossibility of fair global governance.
Biermann et al. (2022). Solar geoengineering: The case for an international non-use agreement. WIREs Climate Change, 13(3), e754.
Limitation
Surveys of the public have found little evidence that learning about geoengineering reduces support for emissions cuts; some find it increases concern.
Solar geoengineering cannot be governed fairly. A single global thermostat would create winners and losers in rainfall and temperature, with no legitimate way to decide whose climate is optimised.
Harvard's SCoPEx balloon experiment, which planned to release small amounts of material in the stratosphere, was halted after objections including from the Saami Council in Sweden, and cancelled in 2024.
Harvard SCoPEx project announcements (2021, 2024); Saami Council letter (2021).
Limitation
Governance problems are an argument about deployment. Research, including governance research, could help address them.
Research creates institutional momentum: careers, funding streams and constituencies that push toward deployment, a "slippery slope" seen in other technologies.
Unauthorised geoengineering attempts have already occurred: the startup Make Sunsets released sulphur dioxide balloons in Mexico in 2022, prompting Mexico to announce a ban on solar geoengineering experiments.
Mexico Secretaría de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales announcement (Jan. 2023).
Limitation
This example arguably supports the case for public research and regulation rather than a vacuum.
Solar geoengineering would not reduce CO2 levels or ocean acidification.
Large volcanic eruptions have temporarily cooled the global climate.
Deployment at scale would require international governance that does not currently exist.